State Farm® Insurance Agent Andy McMahon
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Julie Johnson
August 7, 2026
"My uncle had a house fire, ServiceMaster was quickly in contact with my family to start the restoration process. We were told by Reggie Boggs living expenses would be covered but when we asked if assisted living was an option because my uncle is disabled and in a skilled nursing facility, he told us he’d check on that and get back to us. Almost 2 weeks passed and we call him again, he’s out of the office and a “Brianna” calls and was extremely rude with me but also my elderly mother. She said I was mistaken and wished to only speak to one family member because it was easier for her. This is how you treat customers of over 20 years?"
Michelle Gebers
August 7, 2026
"She walked me through a couple of things I had questions about, and was just a pleasure to speak with."
"Wow, thank you for the 5-star review, Michelle! We truly appreciate your support. If you ever need anything, we’re just a call or message away. "
Dylan Price
August 4, 2026
"Provides great service. My agent and his team are good people. Very kind and understanding. I have two vehicles. I got a good deal on the monthly payment. Highly recommend State Farm to anyone looking to get insurance!"
"Thank you so much for your kind review, Dylan! If you need insurance assistance, we are just an email or call away! - Andy McMahon, your State Farm Agent "
Avi M. (Tunsy)
July 21, 2026
"Nick was very helpful and very detailed. I'm not very savvy to car insurance and warranties. I just say full coverage. But he explained everything in detail and was very patient with me."
"Thanks so much for the 5 stars! We really appreciate your support - it means a lot to all of us here on Andy McMahon’s team. "
JOHN GRANT
July 9, 2026
"My experience with Jay was very great, professional and top
notch. Look forward to having his as my agent and further contact"
"Thanks so much for the amazing review, JOHN! We really appreciate your support here in Mason . If you ever have any questions or need insurance assistance in the future, we are just a message away!"
Cece
July 6, 2026
"Great customer service. Great deals"
"Cece, thank you for your kind review. We deeply appreciate your feedback of State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team here in our Mason office. "
Amanda Robinson
June 30, 2026
"I had an amazing experience with my State Farm agent. From the very beginning, he took the time to explain everything in detail and made sure I understood my coverage and all of my options. He was patient, kind, and never made me feel rushed or pressured.
What really stood out was how he helped take the stress off my shoulders. He listened to my concerns, answered every question I had, and worked hard to find me an even better deal than I expected. I was honestly surprised by how much he was able to help me save while still getting the coverage I needed.
Excellent customer service like this is hard to find. If you’re looking for someone who is knowledgeable, honest, and truly cares about helping people, I highly recommend him. Thank you for making the entire process easy and stress-free!"
"Thank you for your kind review of State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team. We appreciate it!"
Tom Swager
June 30, 2026
"I'm a very happy long term customer. The team is excellent and conducts thorough reviews of your insurance needs and makes sure you have appropriate coverage, but also not over insured. The agency is easy to communicate with and prices for my home, auto and liability policies have always been very competitive."
"Tom, thank you for your wonderful review of State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team!"
Meghan Liu
June 24, 2026
"Great experience speaking with Nick! He explained things clearly and patiently and walked me through the process. I came to him knowing not really a lot about insurance since I am a first time home buyer. He did a great job on drafting reasonable priced policies based on my situation!"
"Thank you for your wonderful feedback. We are pleased to hear that you had a positive experience with us here on State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team. "
Scott Schumacher
June 18, 2026
"Today I had another great experience at Andy's office. Lisa helped me with a technical issue signing into the State Farm app & she was extremely helpful!"
"Thanks Scott! We appreciate you. "
Julia Page
June 3, 2026
"Phone call to discuss our policies was very informative. Nick did a good job of educating us on our current coverage and where we might need adjustments. But he did not seek to increase our coverage if not needed."
"Julia, thank you for your kind review. We deeply appreciate your feedback of State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team here in our Mason office. "
Brent McNeil
May 20, 2026
"Shelia was very helpful today! Thank you!"
"Wow, thank you for the amazing 5-star review! It means a lot to us here in Mason to know that you had such a wonderful experience with us here on State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team. Thank you so much for the 5-stars, Brent! We really appreciate your feedback and are always here to help with any insurance needs you have. Feel free to reach out to us here on State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team anytime. "
Rhonda Simmons
May 19, 2026
"Nick was very thorough with my annual review and I appreciate them helping us to stay on top of knowing what coverage we have and if there needs to be any adjustments made. This way there are no surprises!"
"We are grateful for your 5-star review, Rhonda! Thanks for taking a moment to share your positive rating of State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team here in Mason . "
Mike Lechter
May 16, 2026
"Nick was able to save me about 15% on my home, auto and umbrella. Straight forward to work with and worked very quickly to get my policies moved over to StateFarm. With these kinds of things you just hope you never need to file a claim but I suspect that’d be just as smooth."
"We really appreciate your 5-star review, it means a lot to us! We are always happy to help with anything insurance related—whether it is finding the right coverage or answering general questions."
Cole Grever
May 15, 2026
"Davonte McGhee was super helpful in picking out what works best for me and my family. Would highly recommend his help for any type of insurance needs!"
"Thank you so much for the 5-stars, Cole! We hugely appreciate your feedback. If you ever want to chat about your insurance needs, we are here and happy to help! "
William Smith
May 15, 2026
"Looking to make a switch for Vehicle Insurance. Davonte was very helpful and informative."
"Thank you for the 5-star review, William! Here on State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team, we are proud to serve our community and appreciate your recognition. "
Charlie Lind
May 15, 2026
"Davonte was very helpful getting my insurance for my new car"
"Thank you for the fantastic review, Charlie! We are always here to help with your insurance needs here in Mason . "
Ross Flenniken
May 15, 2026
"Makes insurance easy. Will be going through Davonte and Andy McMahon whenever another policy is needed. Thank you!"
"Thank you for the fantastic review, Ross! We are always here to help with your insurance needs here in Mason . "
Luke Sulken
May 15, 2026
"Davonte was a big help in finding me the best renters insurance. After shopping around with a couple other companies it was by far the best price and coverage. The communication and support throughout the process was top tier!"
"Thank you for the fantastic review, Luke! We are always here to help with your insurance needs here in Mason . "
Conner Adams
May 15, 2026
"Davonte is the best!! Thanks for all your help"
"Wow, thank you for the 5-star review, Conner! We deeply appreciate your support! If you ever need any help or have any questions on anything insurance related, please do not hesitate to get in touch!"
Pedro Bianchi
May 15, 2026
"Davonte flipped and reset my feelings on insurance companies!"
"Thank you so much for the 5-star review of State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team! We deeply appreciate your kind words here in Mason . "
Kat Lehmkuhl
May 15, 2026
"When a stranger's SUV slammed into my house at 9 am on a Monday, Leesa Burgos, a State Farm agent, sat with me for 2 hours on the phone with the SUV owner's insurance agency. She knew the rules of the process so that the other agency picked up the cost. Our case was accepted the same day by the other agency, so that we did not even have a deductible. Leesa fought for me as a client so that my family got the best outcome. I am deeply grateful for her help and expertise."
"We really appreciate your 5-star review, it means a lot to us! We are always happy to help with anything insurance related—whether it is finding the right coverage or answering general questions."
Angela Derifield
May 15, 2026
"Got me a great rate for my commercial truck! Very nice young man! Thank you for all your help."
"Thank you for your 5-star review. We appreciate your feedback and are pleased to know you had a positive experience with State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team. Should you have any further questions or require assistance, please do not hesitate to contact us here in Mason ."
Alicia Rivera
May 4, 2026
"Nick Tymitz Is absolutely amazing!!! He helped my husband and I get car insurance and renters insurance at an affordable rate and he was so kind and very informative! We are in our 20s and people tend to rush us/get judgy when we ask questions sometimes and Nick answered all my questions in a very kind, honest and informative way!! He’s the best!"
"Wow, thank you for the amazing 5-star review! It means a lot to us here in Mason to know that you had such a wonderful experience with us here on State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team."
Reece Morris
April 17, 2026
"Lisa was very helpful!"
"Wow, thank you for the amazing 5-star review! It means a lot to us here in Mason to know that you had such a wonderful experience with us here on State Farm Agent Andy McMahon’s Team."